Whether we realize it or not, we all carry limiting beliefs about who we are.
Maybe you see yourself as the shy one, the inconsistent one, or the person who starts things but never follows through.
At some point in the past, you picked up this belief. And now, even when parts of your life have changed, that old belief still follows you around, influencing not just how you see yourself, but how others see you, too.
Neuroscience offers some fascinating insights into how this happens, and more importantly, how we can begin to change it.
Here are five ways your brain creates and reinforces your identity, and how you can use those same mechanisms to rewire the beliefs and behaviors that no longer serve you.
1. Your Brain Is Constantly Learning Who You Are
According to psychology, we have something called self-schemas: mental frameworks that organize your beliefs about who you are.
These develop over time through your experiences, successes, failures, feedback from others and, most importantly, the meaning you attach to them.
For example, maybe you struggled with maths at school, received a few disappointing test results, and were told you were more of an artistic person.
Eventually, you formed the belief, “I’m just not a maths person,” which influenced how you approach anything involving numbers for years to come.
That’s a self-schema.
Psychologist Hazel Markus’ research on self-schemas found that they influence:
- The way we process information about ourselves
- What we remember
- How we predict our future behavior
Your brain uses your self-schemas to make sense of the world. But it doesn’t just remember what happened to you. It remembers what you decided those experiences meant about you.
So, here’s something to try:
Think of one label you regularly use to describe yourself, such as “I’m not disciplined” or “I’m shy.”
Now ask yourself: Is it an objective fact, or a belief you’ve developed through past experiences?
2. Your Brain Keeps Proving The Old Identity Right
Once you’ve developed an idea about who you are, your brain tends to interpret new experiences through that existing belief.
In other words, it keeps looking for evidence that proves your old identity right.
This relates to a process called predictive processing.
Your brain uses your past experiences to anticipate what will happen next, but these expectations can also influence what you notice and how you interpret events.
Let’s say you want to exercise regularly, but you believe you’re someone who never follows through.
You go to the gym three times in one week, and don’t even acknowledge that achievement.
But the very first time you miss a workout, you immediately begin mentally punishing yourself, saying something like, “See? I knew it. This is what we do.”
Even with three successes, your brain focuses only on the one setback. This is known as selective attention, and the more it happens, the more the belief is reinforced.
So here’s a simple exercise to combat this…
Start noticing evidence that challenges your usual self-description.
If you think you’re not creative, notice the clever solutions you come up with to everyday problems.
If you think you’re not a natural leader, notice the moments when people turn to you for advice, or when you step up and take charge without even thinking about it.
3. Every Action Is A Lesson About Who You Are
One of the most amazing things about the human brain is its ability to change throughout our lives.
This is called neuroplasticity.
As we learn, practice, and repeat behaviors, the neural networks involved can actually change and adapt. And this doesn’t stop in childhood. It continues throughout adulthood, meaning your existing patterns aren’t set in stone.
This connects to self-perception theory, developed by psychologist Daryl Bem. The idea is that we sometimes develop beliefs about ourselves by observing our own behaviour.
For example, let’s say you’ve spent most of your adult life insisting that you’re hopeless in the kitchen.
But then, for whatever reason, you decide you’d like to start making more of your own meals.
You start by learning a couple of basic recipes, and at first they don’t go well. But you find that as you keep practicing, you become more confident, start experimenting, and eventually find yourself enjoying cooking and being quite good at it.
So at what point did you become someone who can cook?
There probably wasn’t some dramatic moment when you stood in front of the mirror and announced, “I am a cook!”
You didn’t have to believe you were a cook before you started cooking. You simply started cooking. And eventually, the old description of yourself stopped making sense.
And that’s a principle you can apply to almost anything.
Every time you act like the person you want to become, you give yourself another reason to believe that person is you.
And you can begin surprisingly small with this.
- If you want to become a writer, write a hundred words.
- If you want to become more confident, contribute one idea in a meeting.
- If you want to become someone who takes care of their health, go for a ten-minute walk.
Every action gives you another piece of evidence about who you’re becoming.
4. Your Brain Can Rehearse A Future Identity
Your brain has an extraordinary ability: it can mentally rehearse experiences before they happen.
And interestingly, imagining an action activates some of the same neural systems involved in actually performing it.
Researchers have studied this extensively in areas like motor learning. A fascinating study by neuroscientist Alvaro Pascual-Leone and his colleagues illustrates this.
They had participants learn a simple five-finger exercise on a piano.
One group physically practiced the exercise for two hours a day over five days.
The other group simply imagined playing it. They mentally rehearsed the finger movements without actually moving their fingers.
Researchers found similar changes in the motor cortex in both groups, although physical practice produced greater performance improvements.
So, while imagining something isn’t a substitute for doing it, mental rehearsal can help prepare your brain for new behaviors.
For example, if you want to become more confident speaking up, picture yourself contributing to an upcoming meeting. Imagine feeling hesitant, taking a breath, and sharing your thoughts anyway.
5. Your New Identity Needs To Survive Real Life
Anyone can feel like a completely new person on Sunday evening with a fresh notebook and a burst of motivation.
The real test comes on Wednesday, when you’re tired, behind schedule, and life isn’t going to plan.
This is where a lot of identity change falls apart. Because you haven’t yet figured out how to behave differently when your circumstances aren’t ideal.
But there’s a very useful piece of research that can help us here.
Psychologist Peter Gollwitzer studied something called implementation intentions. They’re specific if-then plans that connect a situation with an action.
Instead of simply saying, “I’ll exercise more,” you decide: “When it’s 7 am on Monday, I’ll put on my running shoes and go outside.”
Research suggests that if-then plans improve follow-through because you’ve already decided how to respond when a particular situation arises.
But there’s another important step: decide what you’ll do when you slip up.
If you miss a workout, don’t turn it into proof that you’re inconsistent. Simply tell yourself, “I missed today. I’ll try again tomorrow.”
Building a new identity isn’t about getting everything right. It’s about deciding how you’ll respond when things don’t go to plan.
Putting It All Together
In this week’s YouTube video, I walk through these 5 steps in more detail and share personal examples from my own life.
I also show you how to put the steps into action with a simple experiment you can try over the next seven days.
You can watch it here:
I’d love to know: what’s one identity you’re ready to leave behind, and what are you becoming instead?
Tell me in the comments!
Resources
- Download the first chapter of my book for free: https://go.kimfoster.com/excerpt
- Dr. Kim on Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/drkimfoster/






